What Did You Hire Us For?

I'm on a call and a customer asks me to walk them through it. Are we handling their whole marketing effort, or mainly the social side?

They're not upset. They're not saying nothing's getting done... they actually point out the work they've seen. They just want to know what they should expect us to own, and honestly that's a harder question than "are you guys doing anything."

My first instinct is to pull up the list. Here's what we posted, here's what we shot, here's what we shipped. And I can feel how wrong that answer is while I'm reaching for it, because they didn't ask what we did. They asked what we're responsible for. Those two overlap a lot. They're not the same thing.

I. Full service doesn't answer anything

Full service looks great on a website. It's reassuring, it sounds like you'll never have to worry about anything again. It falls apart the second somebody needs to know whether a specific thing is going to happen next week.

Who's making it? Who's posting it? Who's watching what happens after it goes live? Where does the customer's part start and ours stop?

The label doesn't answer any of that. It just gives both sides room to assume the answer is obvious, and it's almost never obvious to both sides at the same time.

It gets worse as the work grows. You start by helping with one urgent thing, then another request comes in, then another part of the business starts showing up in the same meetings with the same people, and before long there's a whole relationship built around the work but nobody ever went back and redrew the lines.

I'm not saying every extra ask is a problem. Being useful means being flexible, and I don't want us turning every reasonable request into a contract reading. But flexible without a shared understanding just means the customer is guessing at the arrangement based on whatever we did most recently.

II. We drifted, and that's on us

In a later planning conversation I told them straight up... we'd drifted into a broader pile of work, and managing that was our job, not theirs.

The proposal was to tighten the paid side around a clear focus and let the person who already owned their organic work keep owning it. Simple. Maybe overdue.

It would've been really convenient to say the customer misunderstood. It also would've been wrong. We write the proposals. We know the difference between making an asset and managing everything that happens around it. We're the ones who understand how agency work gets divided up, so we're the ones who have to make it understandable before it turns into a meeting topic.

A customer shouldn't have to learn how our industry is structured just to know what they hired us to do.

And if the structure we sold doesn't fit the work anymore, we have to say that out loud. Shipping good pieces doesn't fix a broken arrangement. It just hides it longer.

III. A smaller scope can be a bigger commitment

I know a tighter scope can sound like we're offering to do less. I think it's usually the opposite... it's what gives the commitment enough shape to actually hold weight.

When we know exactly which part is ours, we can see the handoffs. We can spot the job nobody owns instead of assuming it's floating around somewhere inside full service. We can tell the customer what needs to happen around our piece instead of pretending our piece is the whole thing.

That doesn't mean making them manage a dozen specialists. It means we understand the whole assignment well enough to name our part of it honestly.

And it's not a one-time conversation you file away. A launch changes the business. An offer changes. Somebody new joins the team on their side. When the thing the arrangement was built around moves, the arrangement deserves another look.

I want The Montgomery Group trusted with work that actually matters. That means asking whether we're still aimed at the job we agreed to, especially when the calendar is full and the deliverables look great.

The list of finished work is useful. It's just not an answer.

If they have to ask what they hired us for, we already owe them the answer.